Skip to content
Made the CutSign in
Chart · 95 rankings

Best Xbox Games

How many of the 95 rankings — not the rank
1Red Dead Redemption 2on 23 of 95 rankings2Elden Ringon 21 of 95 rankings3The Witcher 3: Wild Hunton 16 of 95 rankings4Mass Effect 2on 11 of 95 rankings5The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrimon 17 of 95 rankings6Fallout: New Vegason 12 of 95 rankings7Cyberpunk 2077on 10 of 95 rankings8Hollow Knighton 8 of 95 rankings9Outer Wildson 6 of 95 rankings10Minecrafton 5 of 95 rankings11Portal 2on 4 of 95 rankings12Dark Soulson 9 of 95 rankings13Dragon Age: Originson 6 of 95 rankings14Dark Souls IIIon 5 of 95 rankings15Halo 3on 5 of 95 rankings16Clair Obscur: Expedition 33on 4 of 95 rankings17NieR: Automataon 6 of 95 rankings18Red Dead Redemptionon 6 of 95 rankings19Halo: Combat Evolvedon 5 of 95 rankings20Undertaleon 5 of 95 rankings21Borderlands 2on 4 of 95 rankings22Mass Effecton 4 of 95 rankings23Resident Evil 4on 3 of 95 rankings24Grand Theft Auto: San Andreason 3 of 95 rankings25Hadeson 3 of 95 rankings26Terrariaon 3 of 95 rankings27Sekiro: Shadows Die Twiceon 4 of 95 rankings28Hunt: Showdown 1896on 2 of 95 rankings29Hollow Knight: Silksongon 2 of 95 rankings30Dishonoredon 2 of 95 rankings31Omorion 3 of 95 rankings32Castlevania: Symphony of the Nighton 5 of 95 rankings33Mafiaon 2 of 95 rankings34Overwatchon 2 of 95 rankings35It Takes Twoon 2 of 95 rankings36Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 3on 2 of 95 rankings37Fable IIIon 2 of 95 rankings38Fallout 3on 3 of 95 rankings39Grand Theft Auto Von 2 of 95 rankings40Batman: Arkham Knighton 4 of 95 rankings41Titanfall 2on 3 of 95 rankings42Call of Duty: Black Opson 3 of 95 rankings43Doom Eternalon 2 of 95 rankings44Rocket Leagueon 2 of 95 rankings45BioShockon 5 of 95 rankings46Deep Rock Galacticon 2 of 95 rankings47Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfareon 2 of 95 rankings48The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivionon 2 of 95 rankings49Batman: Arkham Cityon 2 of 95 rankings50Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republicon 4 of 95 rankings51Mass Effect 3on 2 of 95 rankings52Destinyon 2 of 95 rankings53Half-Life 2on 3 of 95 rankings54Coffee Talkon 1 of 95 rankings55Dishonored 2on 1 of 95 rankings56Yakuza 0on 1 of 95 rankings57Monster Trainon 1 of 95 rankings58Rain Worldon 1 of 95 rankings59Path of Exileon 1 of 95 rankings60Final Fantasy XII: The Zodiac Ageon 1 of 95 rankings61Resident Evil 2on 1 of 95 rankings62TimeSplitters: Future Perfecton 1 of 95 rankings63Shadow of the Tomb Raideron 1 of 95 rankings64River City Ransomon 1 of 95 rankings65Sonic Adventure 2on 1 of 95 rankings66The Long Darkon 1 of 95 rankings67Tom Clancy's Splinter Cellon 1 of 95 rankings68Halo: Reachon 1 of 95 rankings69Sayonara wild heartson 1 of 95 rankings70Superliminalon 1 of 95 rankings71Blue princeon 1 of 95 rankings72Dispatchon 1 of 95 rankings73Deus Ex: Human Revolutionon 1 of 95 rankings74Dragon Age: Inquisitionon 2 of 95 rankings75Sifuon 1 of 95 rankings76Metaphor Refantazioon 1 of 95 rankings77Kerbal Space Programon 2 of 95 rankings78Brothers: A Tale of Two Sonson 1 of 95 rankings79Resident Evil Villageon 1 of 95 rankings80To the moonon 1 of 95 rankings81Keeperon 1 of 95 rankings82Indikaon 1 of 95 rankings83Animal wellon 1 of 95 rankings84Alterson 1 of 95 rankings85Citizen sleeper 2on 1 of 95 rankings86Gone homeon 1 of 95 rankings87Fallout 4on 2 of 95 rankings88Apex Legendson 1 of 95 rankings89Slime Rancheron 1 of 95 rankings90Katana ZEROon 1 of 95 rankings91Return of the Obra Dinnon 1 of 95 rankings92The Witnesson 2 of 95 rankings93Bastionon 1 of 95 rankings94Bioshock infiniteon 1 of 95 rankings95Team Fortress 2on 2 of 95 rankings96Assassin's Creed IIIon 1 of 95 rankings97Max payne 2on 1 of 95 rankings98Dune awakeningon 1 of 95 rankings99Final Fantasy X HD Remasteron 1 of 95 rankings100Monster Hunter: Worldon 1 of 95 rankings
Beside this chart
Best Games of All TimeEvery top list
Genres
Best Adventure Games98 rankingsBest RPGs98 rankingsBest Shooter Games82 rankingsBest Puzzle Games55 rankingsBest Platformer Games52 rankingsBest Strategy Games51 rankingsBest Hack & Slash Games40 rankingsBest Simulation Games36 rankings
Platforms
Best PlayStation Games99 rankingsBest PC Games96 rankingsBest Nintendo Switch Games73 rankingsBest Nintendo Switch 2 Games56 rankings
Modes
Best Multiplayer Games9 rankingsBest Co-op Games2 rankings
Years
Best Games of the 2010s93 rankingsBest Games of the 2000s73 rankingsBest Games of the 2020s58 rankingsBest Games of the 1990s44 rankingsBest Games of 201839 rankingsBest Games of 201538 rankingsBest Games of 201037 rankingsBest Games of 201735 rankings
Combined charts
Best Xbox RPGs89 rankingsBest Xbox Adventure Games82 rankings
How this ranking is made
The answer

According to Made the Cut's census of 95 independent rankings, recounted 21 October 2026, the best Xbox game is Red Dead Redemption 2, followed by Elden Ring and The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt.

How this is counted

This chart counts 95 ranking sources, one voice each: the published ranking of games from that source with the most titles on Xbox, cut down to those titles, in the order that source listed them. A title's place is its average position across all sources counted: a title someone left off their ranking counts as tied with their last place (here, that source ranked titles of this kind and left this one out). A small pull toward the middle keeps one enthusiastic list from crowning a #1. Every title in the computed chart has a numbered position, with its source count shown beside it. It is recounted whenever a ranking is published, changed or removed, last on 21 October 2026. Member rankings and attributed external lists use the same calculation. Multiple lists from one member or external author count once; linked slices add no extra vote. Frozen links, private or unlisted lists and unmatched titles are never counted. The full method.

Rankings behind this chart
My Top 100vintik91 · @6c3tk3zAny-Ball-1267: top 5 gamesSource: Any-Ball-1267 on RedditBraquiador: top 5 gamesSource: Braquiador on RedditReplubic: top 5 gamesSource: Replubic on RedditPrestonluv: top 5 gamesSource: Prestonluv on RedditSavageLove2004: top 5 gamesSource: SavageLove2004 on RedditCuzTyler: top 5 gamesSource: CuzTyler on RedditDimaTheTiger: top 5 gamesSource: DimaTheTiger on RedditAshyLarry25: top 5 gamesSource: AshyLarry25 on RedditMadLadJoyBoy: top 5 gamesSource: MadLadJoyBoy on RedditJudoka229: top 5 gamesSource: Judoka229 on Redditsexyimmigrant1998: top 5 gamesSource: sexyimmigrant1998 on Reddit

12 of the 95 published rankings of games this counts, in the order they were published.

Your Xbox order, not theirs.Rank games yourself and this chart moves.
Rank games yourself
The full games ranking